write2kill.in | Select writings of Subir Ghosh
 
 
 
  • Sharebar

Rape of sensitivity

Rape of sensitivity
James Michael Brown beat and handcuffed the woman, a Nigerian resident in the town of Vicenza. He raped her vaginally and anally and left her to wander the streets naked in search of help. Photo: Wikimedia Commons

Man, if you are stressed out, you can easily go and rape and practically get away with it these days. No, not by hoodwinking the law, or by finding ways to cirumvent the system. In fact, the law will be on your side and be pretty sympathetic too.

A US soldier who raped a Nigerian woman in Italy has been given a lighter sentence because the court deemed his tour of duty in Iraq had made him less sensitive to the suffering of others. James Michael Brown beat and handcuffed the woman, a Nigerian resident in the town of Vicenza. He raped her vaginally and anally and left her to wander the streets naked in search of help. [Link]

But the Italian court felt, "The prolonged psychological stress to which the accused was subjected, and the lowered importance he ended up giving to the life and well-being of those around him, can only have influenced the committing of the crimes."

"He thought he was frequenting a prostitute," Antonio Marchesini (Brown's lawyers) said. "She denied she was a prostitute, but the court ruled she was a prostitute. Still, at the last moment, she did not want to have sex, and the court ruled the sex was not consensual." According to the Reuters report, Brown beat and handcuffed the Nigerian woman, raped her, and left her to wander the streets naked in search of help. [Link]

As if all we needed all this while was a precedent to justify rapes. If this Brown is insensitive to the suffering of others now, whatever might have caused it, then he is not fit to be let loose on any society. But the court thinks otherwise. And you now have the precedent that rapists can use as a justification. Some justice.

The consequences of the court order makes it a scary thought if seen in the backdrop of what American soldiers have been doing in Iraq. Subjected to stress in their Bushesque quest of hunting for weapons of mass destruction that did not exist, they have not only been raping Iraqi women soldiers [Link] but their own female compatriots [Link] with impunity as well.

The argument about psychological stress being a rationalisation for rape is too much to take. A man who rapes cannot be of sound mind anyway. Stressed out or otherwise. And the fact that this man was a soldier ought to have gone against him, than in his favour. Soldiers the world over, in conflict situations, use rape as a weapon. When guns don't solve the problem for them, they indulge in psychological warfare. And even when they exit the war theatres, they remain trapped in this mindset.

Sick minds are sick minds. They ought to be barred for life.

 
Related links on the Internet
 
 
Daily Newsletter
Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner
Random Pick: Wildlife
Vultures still in peril as pharmacies and farmers flout deadly diclofenac ban
September 13, 2011 | Vultures still in peril as pharmacies and farmers flout deadly diclofenac ban: Over a third of Indian pharmacies continue to sell diclofenac to livestock farmers. Manufacture and sale of this drug for veterinary use has been banned in India since 2006, because of its toxicity... Continue reading Vultures still in peril as pharmacies and farmers flout deadly diclofenac ban
Random Pick: People
NGT orders status quo on Challakere projects
August 23, 2013 | NGT orders status quo on Challakere projects: In a decision, being described as unprecedented and significant, the National Green Tribunal has ordered a status quo on all project activities proposed in the ecologically-fragile Amrit Kaval... Continue reading NGT orders status quo on Challakere projects
Random Pick: Human Rights
The BlackBerry, the elite, and a question of civil liberties
August 15, 2010 | The BlackBerry, the elite, and a question of civil liberties: The Indian elite is known for many things good, bad and ugly, its ostrich syndrome being one. Any ill that does not plague it, simply does not exist. A liberalised socio-economic regime gives it all... Continue reading The BlackBerry, the elite, and a question of civil liberties
Random Pick: Health
Curfew forces MSF to stop mental health services in Kashmir
September 18, 2010 | Curfew forces MSF to stop mental health services in Kashmir: Humanitarian medical aid organisation Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) has stopped its mental health services in Kashmir due to increasing violence and a round-the-clock curfew. Kashmir has been... Continue reading Curfew forces MSF to stop mental health services in Kashmir
Random Pick: Development
Panchayati Raj has helped in reporting of crimes against women
October 2, 2011 | Panchayati Raj has helped in reporting of crimes against women: Reported violence against Indian women is on the rise. But that’s not because of what you think. A recent study argues that this increase reflects growing willingness to report violence against... Continue reading Panchayati Raj has helped in reporting of crimes against women
Random Pick: Media
When conservationists and journalists fail, wildlife is the loser
May 29, 2011 | When conservationists and journalists fail, wildlife is the loser: Talking about the insufficient coverage of wildlife issues in the news media is akin to flogging a dead horse. Certainly in conservationist circles. Conservationists never mince words about what they... Continue reading When conservationists and journalists fail, wildlife is the loser
Random Pick: Politics
The comatose generation
February 1, 2011 | The comatose generation: Talking about the Mumbai terror attacks two years down the line (and while not making this article perfunctorily and callously coincide with the anniversary) is a good idea. Serious issues need to be... Continue reading The comatose generation
Random Pick: Environment
Climate change threatens many tree species
January 25, 2011 | Climate change threatens many tree species: Global warming is already affecting the earth in a variety of ways that demand our attention. Now, research carried out at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem indicates that many tree species might... Continue reading Climate change threatens many tree species