write2kill.in | Select writings of Subir Ghosh
 
 
  • Sharebar

Phooling all the people all the time

The tragedy of the Bandit Queen was that people seem to have forgotten that Phoolan was not a bandit at the time of the rape, and had become one as a consummation of the social injustices meted out to her many a time much before.
[ This write-up, originally penned for a friend's online satire mag way back in August 2001, has been my only published piece written under this pseudonym. Re-publishing it in my blog seemed to be a good idea for its launch. ]

My colleagues were exhilarated. They were agitated too. So the woman who, they claimed, had killed hundreds and got away with it, had finally been gunned down. Quite rightly so, they belligerently maintained. Those who live by the sword must die by the sword, was the apology. But they were disturbed as well. What if the man, who had liquidated her and been subsequently nabbed, were to be hanged for the justice he had meted out? It would become a travesty of justice.

The boss, barely able to gulp down his lunch in this choked state of mind, felt rape is fine, but rape cannot be an excuse for killing your rapists. Yes, nodded the others sotto voce, almost as if rape is the greatest thing than can happen to a woman. The boss, need one reveal, was a man? The physical humiliation and emotional trauma that Phoolan had to undergo during that infamous, seemingly-unending gangrape was perceived as "okay". All in the game, you see.

Had I been made to go through that and if I were to come out alive still, I presented a hopeless case, I too probably would have massacred them in a manner that would have been more bestial than the ignominious rape itself. The three colleagues had a look about them that looked as if they had seen a ghost. This was heretical absurdity at its lunatic best, they thought, but did not think aloud. They just choked over their lunch.

The polemic was not as flimsy and academic as it may have emerged to them. Mine was not about the justification of Phoolan's crimes; the point was about people taking law into their hands whenever they can. The tragedy of the Bandit Queen was that people seem to have forgotten that Phoolan was not a bandit at the time of the rape, and had become one as a consummation of the social injustices meted out to her many a time much before.

Experts of various hues have debated endlessly over the life and times of this woman-wronged-turned-woman-wronging. Paraphrasing that for Jaal, would be a needless waste of space here. So, I wondered, why were my colleagues so livid, and so distraught.

Phoolan Devi

A nudge there, and a poke here, and the answer came gushing out. Violence is a prerogative of men. Like it, or don't like it, it is a fact. And when the story is about a woman killing men, be the reason justified or not, men don't like women who kill men. Call it the penis pride, or whatever filthier you can think of. Female products of this patriarchal society tend to think likewise too.

The point is not about this illiterate of a Parliamentarian from Mirzapur. It is about such venerated, educated elite as my patriarchal and casteist colleagues who have problems galore with Phoolan, be it in her gory life or in her gruesome death. Their contention about people living by the sword and dying by it too holds no water. People who usually die violent deaths are ordinary and peaceloving. Does one need cite instances of wars?

And when one describes Phoolan as an outgrowth of gender exploitation, caste exploitation and class exploitation, one is pooh-poohed as being a "communist" of all things. If speaking one's mind out on eradicating social evils in order to eradicate violence tantamounts to the same as being a communist, it is perhaps better to be a realist and communist than a sexist, a casteist and a sacrosanct hypocrite.

This piece is not about Phoolan, but her vehement "critics" whose chimerical notions about society and its evils is as frivolous as the puerile prattle they engage over cocktails and other tales. The fault lies not in the stars, but in them. They will, forever, be the underlings afflicted by the ostrich syndrome.

But I hope your colleagues are not like mine.

 
 
 
Daily Newsletter
Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner
Random Pick: Cinema
December 4, 2011 | Flashback: The roots of the Hollywood Studio System: Before Hollywood had come an abject failure – that of the Motion Pictures Patent Company (MPPC) to monopolise the film business. This was a cartel of 11 leading American and European producers of... Continue reading Flashback: The roots of the Hollywood Studio System
Random Pick: Politics
October 2, 2010 | New Osama tape talks of climate change and Pakistan flood relief: Al-Qaeda leader, Osama bin Laden, has voiced his concern about climate change and the recent floods in Pakistan, in an audiotape posted on the Internet on Friday. Osama's new tack is being seen as an... Continue reading New Osama tape talks of climate change and Pakistan flood relief
Random Pick: Environment
November 18, 2013 | You’ll be dammed if you talk about small hydel projects: It’s one thing for the corrupt and the indolent to circumvent the system. It’s quite another when the government itself subverts processes to serve vested interests. But that is just what the... Continue reading You’ll be dammed if you talk about small hydel projects
Random Pick: People
April 18, 2012 | Communities can conserve urban architecture: Sometime in the early 1990s, a young Ashoka fellow set about shaking off the archetypal lethargy of old Kolkata. This man, Debashsis Nayak, formed an organisation called the Foundation for the... Continue reading Communities can conserve urban architecture
Random Pick: Human Rights
August 12, 2013 | Acid attack survivors crying to be heard: And when they came for the men, there was nothing left to complain about. The men in question were three unsuspecting individuals who were attacked by detractors in Hubli last week. All three men... Continue reading Acid attack survivors crying to be heard
Random Pick: Media
July 28, 2010 | The Indian media and the stone age: When it comes to Kashmir, you need to reconcile yourself to a few facts. First, you know as little about the goings-on there as the Indian news media condescends to tell you. And second, you know as... Continue reading The Indian media and the stone age
Random Pick: Health
September 26, 2010 | People in OECD countries becoming fatter by the day: People in OECD countries are becoming fatter by the day. One in two people is now overweight or obese in almost half of OECD countries. Rates are projected to increase further and in some countries... Continue reading People in OECD countries becoming fatter by the day
Random Pick: Northeast
October 25, 2011 | Future shock for Kaziranga wildlife: 70 dams in Arunachal: The main threat to Kaziranga National Park in the next 25 years will come not from poachers or encroachers, but the 70 dams that are being built in the Eastern Himalayas of India’s Northeast.... Continue reading Future shock for Kaziranga wildlife: 70 dams in Arunachal