write2kill.in
 
write2kill on Facebook
Random articles

Where news itself is a casualty

Whose media?
These are, we are told, exciting times for those in the media. Not an unsubstantiated, flippant contention one would say if one is abreast of all the investments that have been pouring in, the plethora of newspapers and magazines that are being launched every other day, or for that matter the television channels that are going on air till you stop losing count on your fingers. And if you are aware of all the technological breakthroughs that is driving communications today, you would stand firmly convinced that it is indeed so. The media is in flux, and excitingly so. But then it is also time for us to take stock of things by going beyond the exciting headlines that have been tingling our fertile imagination. We need to look at the trees, and miss the forest, for once. For the sake of convenience and space constraints, this write-up will look only at the news media and desist from pedantic number-crunching. Continue reading

Muivah on the Naga Issue – An Unpublished Interview: II

AZ Phizo
Subir Ghosh: The issue of issue of unity among the Nagas is one of the most written-about subjects. I have raised the issue of the surrenders in 1973 and 1975. Then there was the Phizo-Sakhrie conflict. Do you think such dissension has affected the Naga cause? Continue reading
 

So FTV has hurt the government's sensibilities, again

• Sections:
FTV
So the morally upright Indian government has once again banned FTV, albeit for 10 days. But banned nonetheless. The information and broadcasting ministry, for its part, has been extremely thoughtful in announcing the reason to the public as well. An official statement tells us that it was noticed by the ministry that "A programme on FTV channel was telecast on September 4, 2009 at 15:37:34 hours and 19:01:48 hours showing women with nude upper body which was offending against good taste and decency." The Indian government had banned FTV a few years back on the same grounds. Well, if FTV goes off air it wouldn’t make a fig of a difference either to our GDP or the stock index. It wouldn’t make people in our rural areas any poorer than they already are. If you leave out some diehard fashion aficionados, FTV’s absence is not going to peeve anyone.
Continue reading

Courts have refused to be the moral police. Politicians should follow suit

• Sections:
Courts have refused to be the moral police. Politicians should follow suit
A week or so back, a court dismissed a public interest litigation. It was no landmark judgment in that sense. But it had a message for many morally-upright people in this hallowed land. The Delhi High Court on July 29 dismissed two petitions that sought a stay on the reality show Sach Ka Saamna. The court was clear in what it said, "Our culture is not so fragile that it would be affected by one TV programme." The point is not whether the reality show is good, bad, or ugly. But why many in this country have this innate, burning desire to play the moral police. The problem is compounded by the fact that there are many shades of these morally-condescending lot. Either they indulge in rampant, wanton violence. Like ransacking art galleries. Like tearing apart film theatres. Or, they go to court. You know, like very urbane, urban people. After all, they can take recourse to archaic sections that still lurk in the Indian Penal Code.
Continue reading

A ban-Indian outlook

• Sections:
Deshdrohi
Freedom of expression is slightly more than scribbling poems and tucking them away in your closet, or giving a small, inane speech at a party you might be hosting in your kitchen garden. It is also about putting across a point of view. And it is also about accepting someone else's point of view, however, obnoxious or virulent it might be. The attacks on Biharis, among others, in Mumbai by chauvinist Marathis, and the subsequent display of primeval sentiments by political leaders of Bihari ostensibly as a reaction to the former are both parochial manifestations of divergent points of view. In this backdrop comes a Maharashtra governmental ban on the film called Deshdrohi that purportedly depicts atrocities on North Indians perpetrated by chauvinists in Mumbai, and a Congress leader's call for ban on a play about the Shiv Sena's point of view about the migrants issue in the state capital.
Continue reading

TRAIng times for religion

• Sections:
TV religion
It becomes slightly trying for a blog that stands for freedom of expression to defend religion in any way or on any count. Given the backdrop that most attacks on freedom of expression both in India (primarily from the Hindu right) and cross the world (primarily from the Islamic right) come from those steeped in religion. And, of course, it is ironical that an unrepentant atheist has to write all about it. The other day there was a report in the Hindustan Times about the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) advocating the restriction of religious and spiritual television channels.
Continue reading

Nameless and faceless rightwingers

• Sections:
Art attack
There have been so many incidents involving MF Husain’s art in recent times that one would have lost count. All, not surprisngly, have come from the Hindu fringe of rightists of our country. When alleged Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) activists vandalised the Husain expo at the Constitution Club in New Delhi on August 24, they were able to demonstrate only one thing – that going on a rampage is the only form of self-expression that they know of. It subsequently came to light that the attack was carried out by a hitherto unknown band of Hindu rightwingers called the Shri Ram Sena. This is probably where the problem lies. If you browse through the recent string of attacks by Hindu rightwingers on artists, playrights, couples all in the name of defending the Indian, nay Hindu, values of our society, you will find VHP and its fraternal organisations are not the main perpetrators.
Continue reading

Under fire

• Sections:
Temple trouble
Now human rights bodies have to intervene in temple matters. The Kerala State Human Rights Commission has asked the Travancore Devaswom Board to allow male employees at Lord Ayyappa temple to wear underwear while counting currency notes and coins offered by devotees. All these days, the staff at the hill shrine of Sabarimala had to strip themselves of all clothing, except their dhotis, before entering the counting chamber. The temple authorities enforced this practice after they found that money was being smuggled out, concealed in the undergarments. Some details from the Asia News International (ANI) story: The Kerala State Human Rights Commission (SHRC) has asked the Travancore Devaswom Board to withdraw the dress code that barred staff employees who are trusted with counting money at the shrine from wearing underwear. More than 600 employees engaged in counting currency notes and coins offered by devotees will benefit from Justice N Dhinakar's order.
Continue reading

Reactions on Mallika's dress

• Sections:
Oh Mallika!
Indo-Asian News Service (IANS) has reactions from people in the Hindi film industry on the Mallika dress issue. We are reproducing them all in full. Shilpa Shetty: "I'm just happy that the obscenity case against my dress in Tamil Nadu is quashed. I won.” Malaika Arora: "I think Mallika has become a favourite punching-bag in the press. Leave the girl alone. It's ridiculous. Maybe the moral police in the South should take a closer look at their own films for obscenity.” Rahul Khanna: "I feel quite sad for the moral police. Perhaps they're jealous of Mallika's legs. They seem to have a lot of free time on hand? Why not use it for issues more important than length of skirts?” Hema Malini: "I was there in Chennai. Mallika's dress was looking good. She too was looking very good. But perhaps the dress was a little too short for the occasion. Who knows!”
Continue reading

Husain's paintings not obscene

• Sections:
Not obscene
The Delhi High Court has dismissed criminal proceedings against MF Husain, overruling the charges of obscenity against his paintings. The cases against him were filed in Indore, Rajkot and Pandharpur. Some details from NDTV (May 8): It was his Nude paintings of Hindu gods and goddesses as well as Bharat Mata that created a furor resulting in several threats from right wing Hindu groups like VHP, Shiv Sena, Bajrangdal and the Hindu Jan Jagriti Samiti. Three other cases are still pending against the painter, so this is only a temporary relief. Hussain, 92-year-old has been living virtually in exile in Dubai since 2006, following a series of threats and several court cases that were filed against him. Cases were all transferred to Delhi late last year as per Supreme Court directive. What the judge had to say, according to Hindustan Times:
Continue reading

Hindu outfit and Mallika's outfit

• Sections:
What are you wearing?
Mallika Sherawat is once again in the news, and of course, in trouble. This time she has received a notice from the Chennai Police for a skimpy and translucent dress she wore at a show in the city recently. The one gunning for Sherawat is the Hindu Makkal Katchi (HMK). Now, don't you dare take umbrage at HMK's outrage, for you will get it back in turn. They are quite a hypersensitive lot. HMK activist S R Kaniraj has lodged a complaint with the Periyamet police station in Chennai, saying that Mallika has "caused mental agony and hurt to the sentiments of the people of Tamil Nadu by wearing a revealing mini skirt, exposing her back and sitting cross legged in front of the Chief Minister M Karunanidhi." HMK wants the police to take action against Mallika. But the police decided to consult some lawyers before acting. The lawyers said that how to dress was one's personal matter.
Continue reading

Cheerleaders case updates

• Sections:
Cheers!
West Bengal Sports Minister Subash Chakraborty is pleading for the ban on cheerleaders in West Bengal and has even sought the intervention of Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharyya. Three ministers—Kshiti Goswami, Nandgopal Bhattacharya and Pratim Chatterjee—are also lending support to the demand. The Navi Mumbai police seems to have learnt some lessons from fashion shows: “We have been told that any instance of wardrobe malfunctioning will be severely dealt with and hot pants and exposure of deep cleavage will not be tolerated,” said Kaushik Roy, Director IndiaWin Sports. There seems to be no problem in Bangalore: “There is no problem whatsoever,” said Venkat Vardhan of DNA, one of the groups overseeing the conduct of matches in the City. “The problem has been there only at a couple of venues. We haven’t received any directive from the authorities concerned regarding the issue.”
Continue reading