write2kill.in
 
write2kill on Facebook
Random articles

This is one of India's most blacked-out stories

Kondh tribal
It ought to be counted as one of India’s most downplayed stories of the day. It is about the struggle to save an ecosystem called Niyamgiri in Orissa from mining, deforestation and devastation. It is about indigenous people and the rights over their land. Vedanta Resources, a stinking rich British company owned by NRI Anil Agarwal, intends to dig an open-pit bauxite mine in Niyamgiri. This mine will destroy the forests on which the Dongria Kondh depend and wreck the lives of thousands of other Kondh tribal people living in the area. The Supreme Court has given the go ahead for the project, but the battle rages on. Albeit silently. This project, by the way, will also see the death of the centuries-old sacred groves of these people. The Dongria Kondh do not live anywhere else and there are just 8,000 of them left. Continue reading

What's in a name?

Hitler and the monster
With the stage set for the February 15 Assembly polls in the Northeast, a surfeit of names crop up that extend from the ordinary to the bizarre. There are namesakes and names for names' sake. Adolf Hitler, for once, is not a member of the German National Socialist Party. He is not a protagonist of Nazism either for anybody to be alarmed of but just the Congress(I) nominee for the Rangsakona (ST) seat in Meghalaya. Adolf Hitler R Marak is his full name. The Great Dictator of the Third Reich is not the only fiend to contest in the ensuing elections in the state. The very name of a candidate for the Mendipather (ST) constituency would send a shiver down the spine of one too many. One was told that Mary Shelley's monster did destroy its creator. But Frankenstein is alive and kicking for he (Frankenstein W Momin) is the Congress(I) man out here. Continue reading
 

Today's International Tiger Day. Did anyone tell you?

• Date published: September 28, 2008
• Sections:
Share/Save
n/a
One of the few
Photo © MKS Pasha

It is hardly surprising that International Tiger Day, today – September 28, has almost passed by without even a purr. Few know about it, still fewer remember. In all likelihood that is what is going to happen to the tiger too – it will disappear sans even a protesting growl. Its howls, when trapped or killed mercilessly, are never heard anyway. For a nation that cannot even remember its own national animal on International Tiger Day, perhaps that is the fate that starkly awaits the royal beast. Our Prime Minister is too busy getting ready to sleep himself cosy with George W Bush in Washington. Our political leaders back home are too busy tarnishing each other with communal brushes. Our media is too busy writing about them. And in this din, the tiger can hardly make its voice heard.

It would be a cliched understatement to say that the tiger in India stands endangered. From roughly 40,000 tigers at the beginning of the 20th century, their number dipped to 4,334 in 1989, dropped to around 3,750 in 1993, and dwindled further down to 1,411 (minus those in the Sunderbans) in 2008. But the way anthropogenic pressures on tiger habitats are multiplying and the rate at which tiger poachers get away with impunity, tigers will disappear from India earlier than estimated to. Look at the dismal scenario in the backdrop of the so-called tribal bill, and you will give it fewer days in the wild.

To save the tiger, you need to both shelter it from poachers and protect its habitat at the same time. Let’s concentrate on the latter for first.

By protecting tiger habitats, you eventually safeguard the catchment areas of rivers and enable recharging of groundwater sources. There are 35 Tiger Reserves (both existing and proposed) in India. These are sources of 20 major Indian rivers, including Tapti, Narmada, Mahanadi and Ramganga. Besides, there are hundreds of streams and rivulets in these wild lands. These rivers cumulatively and individually, directly and indirectly, shore up the livelihoods of millions of people far removed from these protected areas. So when you save tiger habitats, you do more than just maintaining the pristineness of the tiger homelands at face value. Much more.

The other major threat to tigers comes from illegal trade and poaching. The number of poachers who are nabbed are too few for comfort. The conviction rate is abysmal and the kingpins always escape from the arms of the law. Worse still, most of the hunters who are caught often happen to be hapless villagers who are coerced into the occupation because of lack of alternative means of livelihoods around the Tiger Reserves.

The tiger, you have to agree, cannot be saved in isolation. You need the support of communities who live in and around Tiger Reserves. But the so-called tribal bill, in its present form, is not the right way to go about it. It does, in no way, seek to ameliorate human-wildlife conflict; in fact, the forest rights bill will only exacerbate the problem to an extent that at the end of the day we will neither have wildlife left and nor forests. You will have people everywhere. And they will no longer have the natural resources at their disposal that have been providing them with sustenance all these years.

Without the active support of the common people, who have not been able to make a dime while India has been shining, the tiger does not have much of a bright future. They can not only salvage the habitat, they can stave off poachers too. But for that, these people must be made stakeholders in the survival of the tiger. Treating them like pariahs and jettisoning them away from the tiger hinterlands in a country which has a dubious track in rehablitating oustees, would only make matters worse. Declaring the areas around Tiger Reserves as community reserves should be the first and safest way to get started. The Indian government is well within its rights to do that. But what it is doing right now is playing populist politics in the name of tribals and forest-dwellers.

Then again, to save the tiger you need a lot of money. As of now, something like Rs 10 crore are spent by wildlife organisations on tiger conservation. But that is something of a hand-to-mouth existence. You probably need around Rs 25 crore to do a decent and effective job of it. The chances are that you are aware of this. But what you probably don’t know is that something like 90 per cent of this money comes in from outside. Right, non-Indians not living in this country are probably more concerned about saving the tiger for us. The scope for Indian corporations to donate to the tiger cause is phenomenal. Yet, you don’t see that happening. Don’t ask me why.

Every other day, we are told by all and sundry how inordinately rich we are, how many Indians have made it to the different Forbes lists, and all that. The corporate honchos subsequently blabber to us how proud they are to be Indians, and all that. But their nationalistic pride cannot make them spare even a penny for their national animal. The tiger indeed is unfortunate to exist in a country whose high net worth individuals (HNWI) denizens don’t want to pay for its survival. You think I am growling for the hell of it? If you think I am, you can go back to seeing your favourite reality show on TV.

Well, three of the eight sub-species of the tiger are extinct in the ranges that they existed. One totters on the brink of extinction. The Indian one (Bengal tiger –Panthera tigris tigris) too might soon join its non-existent cousins sooner than later. With that last roar that you are equally unlikely to hear.

Lalita B (not verified) says:
[September 28, 2008; 07:50 PM]
tiger tiger burning bright????!! at least some place someone remembers and thinks it is worth writing about. why are we so apathetic to the plight of our national animal?? why r we blundering on in a direction that will be a death knell not just for the beast, but also, in the long run for us humans.
Salil Sarkar (not verified) says:
[September 28, 2008; 08:28 PM]
Realy so?Today is Tiger Day?Thnx Subir.... All man eater,state eater,culture eater & also liberty eater politicians are busy with there daily menu.Don't disturb them.
Gulnaz Sheikh (not verified) says:
[September 28, 2008; 08:53 PM]
its a pity the tiger is getting extinct.. few species are so majestic as the tiger but more important than that...its the responsiblity of the stronger species which is us to protect the lesser, the weaker species. that is what makes us human according to me.
Nabina Das (not verified) says:
[September 28, 2008; 09:41 PM]
do you have the latest info on Project Tiger figures? somewhere I had read that for every 1 tiger sighted the officials would put down 5 on their books and thus rig the stats... meanwhile, a celebratory "haloom" from me on this day.
Håkan Magnusson (not verified) says:
[September 28, 2008; 10:48 PM]
I didnt know it is the International Tiger Day! I was in Prayair National Park, Kerala in last estern and walk rigt to an Tiger. It was amaising. The world is not the same if the Tiger is gone:-(
admin says:
[September 29, 2008; 12:06 AM]
nabina: HALOOOOOOM!
Sarbani Roy (not verified) says:
[September 29, 2008; 12:46 AM]
Thanks for letting me know.Suddenly remembered Blake's 'Tiger, tiger burning bright......and those last memorble lines...'did He who made the lamb make thee?' Don't you think there should be a lamb's day too?
Rana Chatterjee (not verified) says:
[September 29, 2008; 07:51 AM]
Really..didn't know that..Tiger lovers should visit Bandhav Garh..for tiger sightings ..you cant miss them there..but God know s for how long..if poachers like Sansar Chand are let off on bail right after being arrested..now in hiding and continuing his deals ...
anuragini (not verified) says:
[September 29, 2008; 10:20 AM]
Amidst the "daughters' day" as promoted by Archies... who would remember the Tigers, a dying species! Thank you for bringing it to our notice.
Abhay Sapru (not verified) says:
[September 29, 2008; 09:43 AM]
I agree with you, Subir! It is verily a reflection on the sorry state of affairs in our "Republic of Bananas" (as M.J. Akbar had dubbed our "Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic, Republic" of India in his Byline column last year) that even educated and "discerning" people like us let the International Tiger Day pass us by without a murmur!! The Tiger is a majestic beast, which is being ruthlessly poached, with the poachers ably aided and abetted by the "powers that be", and thus, another species will bite the dust in this magnificent "nuclear powered" republic of ours. My son has never seen a tiger in the wild and I think I should show him one, before the tiger becomes extinct. Disgraceful state of affairs to say the least.
Subir Ghosh (not verified) says:
[September 29, 2008; 09:51 AM]
valid point, abhay. i don't believe in concentrating too much on grooming kids for saving the wildlife... my point is simple... grooming and all are fine.. but by the time these kids grow up to take care of the tiger.. the tiger would have become extinct.... the future actually lies in our hands.. we not-so-young and middle-aged people... to ensure that kids of today do have something to fight for tomorrow, it is imperative that we succeed today..
TIKULI (not verified) says:
[December 6, 2008; 12:43 PM]
I am so glad to see more people joining hands to save tigers .We have lost so many of these majestic animals due to political pressures ,low funds and many such things .Is there anything that we humans have left untouched ..disgraceful ..

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.